ok, so the above issue was fixed, how do you add an authentication provider to Zed module? speaking

UK5DS29L2

ok, so the above issue was fixed, how do you add an authentication provider to Zed module? speaking about

InvalidArgumentException: You must at least add one authentication provider. in file vendor/symfony/security-core/Authentication/AuthenticationProviderManager.php on line 51

EDIT: turning off the debug and in Zed it makes this issue go away, but I'm pretty sure I'd like to have the debug toolbar working

Valerii Trots

Is it about second point here?
https://sprykercommunity.slack.com/archives/CKJRJM5FG/p1609768340068000

UK5DS29L2

no, seems the authentication providers must be somehow defined now (but they weren't in earlier release)

UK5DS29L2

the thread you pointed at seems to be unrelated

Stanislav Matveyev

Hi there, to fix this issue check your \Pyz\Zed\Application\ApplicationDependencyProvider

WebProfilerApplicationPlugin

should be after SecurityApplicationPlugin

UK5DS29L2

🤔

UK5DS29L2

@UKBTMFXMJ https://github.com/spryker-shop/suite/blob/1.7/src/Pyz/Zed/Application/ApplicationDependencyProvider.php
you sure?

UK5DS29L2

I don't see SecurityApplicationPlugin in here

Stanislav Matveyev

if you already installed security-gui instead of auth module - yes

UK5DS29L2

I didn't. That's not what's in this release

UK5DS29L2

so should I just go through suite composer.lock from 1.7 and change my composer.json to lock them to X.Y.Z ?

UK5DS29L2

because right now it doesn't look like composer.json from 1.7 is pointing at stable set of packages, but maybe composer.lock does

Stanislav Matveyev

ok, in this case you don't need Zed SecurityApplicationPlugin, but I don't know what to suggest you with your issue InvalidArgumentException: You must at least add one authentication provider.

UK5DS29L2

I'm so frustrated with this. This release was supposed to provide a stable set of packages and it does anything but that

UK5DS29L2

we have literally spent at least weeks of work on doing trial and error with 1.7 and it doesn't look like we're anywhere close to getting this running.

UK5DS29L2

I'm giving it a last chance by binding the composer.json to versions from 1.7 composer.lock. Not how that should work, but hell, we have used everything else

Stanislav Matveyev

Your project is not a copy of modules and enabled plugins of suite, right? Suite is working and tested.

UK5DS29L2

it is working and tested on versions from composer.lock MAYBE

UK5DS29L2

that's not what you're using if you want to get bugfixes

UK5DS29L2

if you run a composer update on 1.7 is suddenly no longer works, because composer.json points at versions no longer compatible with each other

Stanislav Matveyev

Do you have some enabled Silex services in Pyz? \Silex\ServiceProviderInterface

UK5DS29L2

I did a diff on the whole project and updated the code of all suite files then made sure no missing class is used.
If Silex is used in 1.7, we're using silex. If it's not, we're not

UK5DS29L2

we're as close to core as we can get, everything else is a plugin but it's not the plugin code we have issues with, but the shop itself. Not even homepage works out of the box with the latest packages from composer.json

UK5DS29L2

which is why I'm going to give it a last try and lock everything to versions from lock 1.7. Not how composer should be used, but it's not like we have a choice

Stanislav Matveyev

I agree that composer update should not break the site completely.

UK5DS29L2

shop-suite v1.7, composer.lock, spryker/translator (https://raw.githubusercontent.com/spryker-shop/suite/1.7/composer.lock):

{
            "name": "spryker/translator",
            "version": "1.7.0",

HOWEVER this yields:
ErrorException - FATAL ERROR - Declaration of
Spryker\Zed\Translator\Communication\Plugin\Validator\TranslatorValidatorPlugin::extend(Symfony\Component\Validator\ValidatorBuilderInterface $validatorBuilder, Spryker\Service\Container\ContainerInterface $container): Symfony\Component\Validator\ValidatorBuilderInterface
must be compatible with
Spryker\Shared\ValidatorExtension\Dependency\Plugin\ValidatorPluginInterface::extend(Symfony\Component\Validator\ValidatorBuilder $validatorBuilder, Spryker\Service\Container\ContainerInterface $container): Symfony\Component\Validator\ValidatorBuilder

Why? Because "spryker/validator-extension" is already loaded by:

   {
            "name": "spryker/validator-extension",
            "version": "1.0.0",

I believe because being loaded by and it is a dependency of

        {
            "name": "spryker/validator",
            "version": "1.1.0",

which can be seen at
https://github.com/spryker/validator/blob/1.1.0/composer.json#L13

This however, requires to bump spryker/translator to 1.8 (because this is fixed in 1.8)
https://github.com/spryker/translator/compare/1.7.0...1.8.0#diff-a54591607da18710b6b2419110c5140a474d2786b011411baae8cce06a015f69R35
but 1.8 is nowhere to be found in https://raw.githubusercontent.com/spryker-shop/suite/1.7/composer.lock, because 1.7 is

UK5DS29L2

I'd love to know how did you test this release for stability

UK5DS29L2

this wouldn't work even if I didn't run composer update